We’re constantly bombarded with this advice, “Follow your passion!”. You know the drill – find that one thing you love, do it for a living and you'll never have to "work" a day in your life! It sounds amazing, right?
Problem is, it’s terrible advice.
Cal Newport, author of So Good They Can't Ignore You, totally dismantles this whole “follow your passion” myth and offers a more realistic (and surprisingly more fulfilling!) path to finding work you love.
The main idea of the book is this: rare and valuable skills trump passion. We’ve gotta become so good at something, so uniquely valuable, that we become irresistible! That’s when we have the power to shape our careers, to create opportunities, and to find work that actually lights us up.
Why "Follow Your Passion" is BS
I know, I know. It feels almost sacrilegious to question this “follow your passion” mantra. But stick with me! Here’s why Cal says it’s terrible advice:
Most People Don’t Have a Pre-Existing Passion: Think about it. What’s your passion? It’s a surprisingly hard question to answer! Most of the things we enjoy – sports, video games, hobbies – aren’t things that translate into a reliable career. And even those who do have a passion often find that turning it into a job sucks all the joy out of it.
"If you want to love what you do, abandon the passion mindset ("What can the world offer me?") and instead adopt the craftsman mindset ("What can I offer the world?").
Zero Evidence That Matching Work to Passion = Happiness: There’s simply no scientific proof that matching our work to a pre-existing interest actually makes us more fulfilled! The research points to other factors being way more important for job satisfaction, like autonomy, mastery, and making a positive impact.
The Stories of People Who Love Their Jobs Contradict This Advice: Cal spent years studying the career paths of successful, passionate people. He found that very few actually started with a clear passion. They got good at something, developed rare and valuable skills, and then the passion followed.
Turning Hobbies into Jobs = Recipe for Misery
This is the cliché, right? The amateur baker who opens a bakery and burns out. The passionate gamer who becomes a streamer and hates playing video games.
It’s so common! We take this thing we love, we try to make a living from it, and we end up hating it.
Cal calls this “the craftsman mindset”: It's the pursuit of rare and valuable skills, relentlessly focusing on what you can offer the world.
The craftsman mindset is all about getting better, not just feeling good. It's about mastery, not about matching our work to some elusive pre-existing passion.
Career Capital: The Key to Finding Work You Love
Okay, so if passion isn’t the answer, what is?
It's about building career capital – those rare and valuable skills that make us indispensable.
Here’s the basic idea:
“The more rare and valuable skills you have to offer, the more interesting opportunities will become available.”
Think of it like this. If you walk into a job interview and your only skill is “being passionate,” you won’t get very far. There are tons of passionate people out there and most of them are also broke.
But if you can offer something rare, something valuable – a skill that solves problems, creates value or makes people’s lives better – then you have leverage. You have the power to negotiate, to create opportunities and to find work that aligns with your goals and values.
Two Types of Markets (and How to Win in Each)
Here’s where things get super interesting (and a bit more nuanced!). Cal says there are two main types of career markets and we need to understand which one we’re in to maximize our chances of success:
Winner-Take-All Markets: This is when there’s tons of competition for a small number of spots. Think professional athletes, musicians, YouTubers or even those super-competitive finance or consulting jobs. In these markets becoming truly exceptional at the one skill that matters is the key. It’s about being “so good they can’t ignore you” which is, coincidentally, the title of the book!
Auction Markets: This is when there’s more flexibility and room for different types of career capital. Think marketing, design, engineering, even entrepreneurship. In these markets building rare and valuable combinations of skills is crucial. You’re not just trying to be the best in the world at one thing; you’re creating a unique portfolio of skills and experiences that make you a valuable asset to any team or project.
Finding Your Mission (Without the Magic Fairy Dust)
A lot of people who love their jobs will tell you it’s because they found their “mission.” Their work isn’t just a job; it’s something meaningful and fulfilling that contributes to something bigger than themselves.
But how do we find that mission? Cal says that the most compelling missions aren't something we discover through soul-searching; they’re something we create through hard work, skill acquisition, and a deep understanding of our chosen field.
“The most compelling missions are found at the cutting edge of a particular field, and if you want a particularly interesting mission for your career, you get it by becoming really good at the thing first, and then a mission or a niche or whatever will slowly emerge over time."
This is where those “little bets” from Peter Sims's book, Little Bets, come in! It's about experimenting with different projects, taking on challenges, and learning from those experiences, both the successes and the failures. As we build our skills and gain a deeper understanding of our field, those “aha!” moments, those “this is what I was meant to do!” feelings, will naturally emerge!
Leveraging Our Skills to Shape Our Lives
The big takeaway from So Good They Can’t Ignore You is this: we can’t demand those great jobs, those fulfilling careers, or those dreamy lifestyles right out of the gate. We have to earn them!
And here’s how we do it:
Become really good at something. Develop those rare and valuable skills that make you indispensable.
Use those skills as leverage. Negotiate, create opportunities, shape your career toward the things that resonate with you.
Here's where lifestyle-centric career planning comes in.
“You have to, through reflection and experimentation, fix in your mind a very clear image of what you want your life to be like, all the elements of your life. You're really like imagining typical days in a way that just you feel this intimations of: that’s right, that’s what I want my life to be like.”
This is about getting clear on what’s truly important to you.
Where do you want to live?
What kind of work do you want to do?
How do you want to spend your days?
What kind of impact do you want to have?
What does your ideal lifestyle look like?
Once you have that vision locked in, you can use your career capital to shape your work and your life in that direction!
It’s Time to Get Good (So Good They Can’t Ignore You!)
This book is a wake-up call for anyone stuck in the “follow your passion” trap. It’s a roadmap to building a fulfilling, meaningful, and even financially rewarding career – a career that’s so damn good, nobody can say no to you!
Here are some action steps to get started:
Identify your ideal lifestyle: Get clear on your version of a "remarkable life."
Develop rare and valuable skills: What skills will make you an asset in your chosen field?
Embrace deliberate practice: Dedicate time each day to pushing yourself beyond your comfort zone and mastering your craft.
Start making those "little bets": Experiment with different projects and learn from your experiences.
Find mentors and guides: Seek out those who are already doing what you want to do, and learn from their example.
Don’t wait for motivation to strike, or for that perfect opportunity to fall into your lap. Take action, build your skills, and become so good that the world can’t ignore you. The passion will follow!
What are your thoughts on this “skills over passion” philosophy? What steps will you take to build your career capital and create a life you love? Let’s discuss in the comments!
Comments